Federal law sets schools up to fail, officials say
Email | Print | 619 views Kate Martin | Skagit Valley Herald
August 31, 2008 - 08:00 PM

School officials across Skagit County say the goals for student achievement set forth in the federal No Child Left Behind program are a “moving target” that will doom practically every public school in the country to failure in six years.

“It’s impossible to keep progressing at this level,” said Superintendent Wayne Robertson of the Conway School District. “It’s like chasing a goal that keeps accelerating and keeps getting more rigorous at the same time our resources to allocate toward it diminishing.”

Every three years, the standards are set a little higher. By 2014, all students in the country — 100 percent — must pass their state’s standardized test, or their schools are deemed failures.

Last week, the state released results from this state’s standardized test, the Washington Assessment of Student Learning. Test scores determine whether a school succeeds or fails.

The goal of No Child Left Behind — holding teachers and schools accountable for the learning of children in their classrooms — is laudable, said Superintendent Laurel Browning of the Burlington-Edison School District.

“I know the intent is to make sure we look at data and make sure we don’t ignore students,” Browning said.

But in reality, the federal measurements don’t track progress at all, several school officials say.

“We would prefer the state and federal government look at student improvement over time,” said Assistant Superintendent Kathy Ehman of the Sedro-Woolley School District. “But that’s not the way it’s measured, so we have to play the hand we’re dealt.”

Superintendent Tim Bruce of La Conner School District said his district focuses on individual students instead of grade levels.

“I consider the WASL one assessment of the many that we do,” Bruce said. “Over the long haul we are more concerned about that individual’s achievement and how we’re going to send them out as graduates.”

The WASL, he said, is “one measurement in time.”

“We do know what our challenges are long before these test results come out,” Bruce said.

All districts in Skagit County use the data to measure year-to-year student growth, instead of comparing the same grade level over multiple years, as No Child Left Behind is set up to do.

This year, 628 schools failed statewide. That compares with 280 in 2007. In Skagit, 30 schools or education centers failed compared with 20 in 2007.

When a school meets testing standards, it is considered to have met adequate yearly progress. When the school misses the mark in just one of 37 testing categories, schools can fall into several categories of schools that need improvement. Districts are measured on up to 111 categories.

There are reasons districts appear to be doing worse over time.

Every three years, the percent of students who must pass the WASL increases. This year was a step-up year, and schools had to show as much as 20 percent improvement in the previous year’s scores.

Also, data is being tracked differently. Two years ago, schools only tested fourth-, seventh- and 10th-grade students. Today, students in third through eighth grades, and 10th graders, are tested.

Schools that do poorly according to federal guidelines receive no money from the federal government for the changes they are required to make, such as after-school tutors and crafting school-improvement plans.

“It’s kind of programmed for misery, if you ask me,” Robertson said. “Pretty soon everyone will be (below standard), and it won’t matter.”

Mark Venn, superintendent of Sedro-Woolley School district, compared the goals a school is expected meet to an all-star athlete.

“If you miss one cell, you’re a loser,” Venn said. “If you look at a baseball player and they’re hitting 36 of 37 times they’re up (to bat), they are making millions of dollars, and they’re the best baseball player in history.”

Combined with the other “moving targets” is math, Browning said. The state has changed the material that students must know for the 2010 WASL.

“It will be a challenge to continue to meet AYP (adequate yearly progress,” Browning said.

There is a chance, albeit a small one, that No Child Left Behind will not be reauthorized, or it could be changed by the next president. Nathan Olson, spokesman for the Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction, said his office has “no idea” what presidential candidates John McCain or Barack Obama plan to do with the law.

For now the Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction is operating under the assumption that No Child Left Behind will remain, and with it, the eventual “impossible” goal of a 100 percent student pass rate.

• Kate Martin can be reached at 360-416-2145 or at .

On the Web: To view your school or district’s results, visit http://reportcard.ospi.k12.wa.us, and select AYP from the tab above, then select the school district and the school.






More Local News

Top Jobs

Mechanic's Helper, food equipment & refrigeration. Background and drug screen. $10-$15 DOE. 360-202-9460


Project Manager Assistant/ Grants Coordinator The Public Works Department of the Swinomish Tribal Community has an opening for a Project Manager Assistant/Grants Coordinator. The position will oversee assigned aspects of Tribal development projects and programs relating to their development, design, construction, inspection, and administration. 5 years of administrative experience, with at least two years work experience in an area related to work responsibilities. A high school diploma or equivalent is a must. Bachelor's Degree desired. Salary is up to $21.00 an hour with full benefits. Request a Swinomish Tribal Community application by calling (360) 466-1216 or e-mail to wbill@ swinomish.nsn.us Mail cover letter and resume along with the application to: Swinomish Tribal Community, Human Resource Office, 11404 Moorage Way, LaConner, WA. 98257


Bilingual Apartment Maintenance Worker needed for affordable farm worker apartments. Must have two years experience, be personable and professional, and have valid WA State drivers license, insurance and reliable vehicle. Send resume to Almap@ccsww.org or call 360-424-3883


EXPERIENCED CASHIERS F/T and P/T positions available. Must be able to work nights & weekends. Competitive pay. 2 weeks paid vacation. Bonus plan after 6 months of employment. Apply in person at: Swinomish Chevron located near Northern Lights Casino


P/T cooks, day or night, 20 hrs. per week, Tues.-Sat. Empire Ale House, 314 W. Gates St., Mount Vernon. 360-336-9944


OFFICE ASSISTANT Superior organizational skills, professional with public, ability to prioritize and multi-task, proficient with Word, work in team-based environment, additional hours during summer season. Min. of 2 yrs exp. in similar position. F/T M-F 8-5 and 1 or 2 Sat. per mo, 9-2. $10.50/hr. Raises and benefits avail. in 3 mo. Submit cover letter with resume to: HR Dept., PO Box 822, Anacortes, WA 98221


Cook for fast paced kitchen, must work clean, 1-3 shifts/week. Apply in person Thur. or Fri. 7-11am, Edison Cafe, 5797 Main St.


OTR, 11 Western States Canada Eligible a Plus Clean MVR & Background APPLY ONLINE www.knighttrans.com 206-767-1041 Class A CDL-Min 6 mos.


P/T Office Cleaning. Exp. Required. Apply at 1404 Riverside, Suite G, MV


Advertising Director Skagit Publishing seeks an Advertising Director with a minimum of five years newspaper or multimedia experience and a proven track record of reaching goals and developing talent for its daily (18,000 Sunday), free and paid weeklies, niche and other products. We're looking for someone who can lead the Advertising staff and direct its overall success. Responsibilities include all aspects of advertising revenue generation; budgeting; and customer, employee and community relations. Key skills will include active participation in overall organizational development and strategic direction. Ability to motivate staff and lead them into the digital age will also be important. We are located in Skagit County in beautiful Northwest Washington near the water and mountains. We offer a competitive salary and benefits package. Send resume, reference and salary requirements to: Skagit Publishing Attn: Stacy De La O P.O. Box 578, Mount Vernon, WA 98273, or email sdelao@skagitpublishing.com. IS AN EQUAL-OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER.