MV man charged in niece’s death
14 Comments | Email | Print | 2900 views Marta Murvosh | Skagit Valley Herald
July 10, 2009 - 08:10 AM
Last Updated: July 10, 2009 - 10:49 AM

CORRECTIONS: This story makes two corrections. Suspect Devin Smith has a prior conviction for disorderly conduct. The deceased toddler tested positive for flu, but negative for swine flu.

MOUNT VERNON — A 2-year-old who died over the weekend was scared of her uncle, who was charged Thursday in the toddler’s death, according to a statement the child’s aunt gave police.

Court records indicate that Sania Amarie Dupree, who died late Saturday or early Sunday, had suffered previous injuries while her aunt, Regina Brantley, was at work.

Prosecutors Thursday filed a magistrate’s warrant on a first-degree murder charge to hold Brantley’s husband, 25-year-old Devin Smith of Mount Vernon, in the Skagit County Jail, prior to filing charges in Skagit County Superior Court. Bail for Smith, who had a previous conviction for disorderly conduct, was set at $1.5 million.

In the week before Sania’s death, her aunt noticed bruises and swelling on the toddler’s face, according to an affidavit filed by prosecutors in Skagit County District Court. Smith told the aunt that Sania hurt herself on a trampoline or fell down the stairs, according to the affidavit.

The statute under which Smith is being held alleges that the girl’s death was caused by extreme indifference, meaning prosecutors contend that he caused the death of another while he was engaged in conduct that created a grave risk of death.

Sania’s mother, meanwhile, is serving in the military in South Korea and now is reportedly heading to Mount Vernon. She had left her daughter in the care of her sister, Brantley, who has a 5-year-old daughter of her own. It was unclear whether that child is related to Smith.

About 12:45 a.m. Sunday, paramedics and police were called to the East Broadway home of a neighbor of Smith’s and Brantley’s. The toddler was declared dead at Skagit Valley Hospital.

Smith told police he awoke to a thumping sound and found Sania on the bathroom floor, according to the affidavit. He told police she wasn’t breathing, but he felt a pulse.

Smith said he tried CPR, then went to a neighbor for help rather than call 911 himself, the affidavit said.

Although Smith denied Sania was hurt while in his care, he later said he dropped her on the garage floor when he took her there to try CPR, the affidavit said. The uncle told police that he and the sleeping 5-year-old were the only people with Sania for the five hours prior to the 911 call.

At the hospital, the pediatrician saw no signs of injury but took a swab to test for the possibility of flu, according to police.

The test for flu was positive, though a test for swine flu was negative. But an autopsy Monday revealed two skull fractures, broken ribs, bruising on her back, an eye injury and a heart injury that could have caused immediate death, according to the affidavit.

The pathologist said the broken ribs were inconsistent with CPR injuries and that Sania had blood clotting in her skull, which indicated a previous injury, the affidavit said.

The aunt told police that Sania had been listless and not eating prior to her death. Brantley also described two different incidents in which Smith had told her that Sania had been injured while reportedly playing on the trampoline. The aunt told police that she was upset that Smith hadn’t told her about the injuries until she asked about the bruises, according to the affidavit.

Smith also told Brantley that Sania had been kicked by the 5-year-old girl, but the aunt told officers the severity of the child’s bruises made her doubt his explanation, the affidavit said.

Brantley told police that “she didn’t know why, but when Smith is gone everything is fine, and when Smith arrives home, (Sania) will say ‘help me’ and then starts crying,” the affidavit said.

Marta Murvosh can be reached at 360-416-2149 or .





Read all 14 comments / share your thoughts
Latest comments

a 2 yr old saying help me? sounds like the aunt is too quick to put the blame on smith as if she has something to hide

Posted August 08, 2009 - 12:03 AM by uhall12

and I’m glad to know that the neighbors would have served justice that night…

Posted July 21, 2009 - 07:49 AM by GrammaGettinGrumpy

In the week before Sania’s death, her aunt noticed bruises and swelling on the toddler’s face
She asked her Auntie “HELP…

Posted July 21, 2009 - 07:47 AM by GrammaGettinGrumpy


Read all 14 comments / share your thoughts


More Local News

Top Jobs

P/T Office Cleaning. Exp. Required. Apply at 1404 Riverside, Suite G, MV


Advertising Director Skagit Publishing seeks an Advertising Director with a minimum of five years newspaper or multimedia experience and a proven track record of reaching goals and developing talent for its daily (18,000 Sunday), free and paid weeklies, niche and other products. We're looking for someone who can lead the Advertising staff and direct its overall success. Responsibilities include all aspects of advertising revenue generation; budgeting; and customer, employee and community relations. Key skills will include active participation in overall organizational development and strategic direction. Ability to motivate staff and lead them into the digital age will also be important. We are located in Skagit County in beautiful Northwest Washington near the water and mountains. We offer a competitive salary and benefits package. Send resume, reference and salary requirements to: Skagit Publishing Attn: Stacy De La O P.O. Box 578, Mount Vernon, WA 98273, or email sdelao@skagitpublishing.com. IS AN EQUAL-OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER.


P/T cooks, day or night, 20 hrs. per week, Tues.-Sat. Empire Ale House, 314 W. Gates St., Mount Vernon. 360-336-9944


EXPERIENCED CASHIERS F/T and P/T positions available. Must be able to work nights & weekends. Competitive pay. 2 weeks paid vacation. Bonus plan after 6 months of employment. Apply in person at: Swinomish Chevron located near Northern Lights Casino


OFFICE ASSISTANT Superior organizational skills, professional with public, ability to prioritize and multi-task, proficient with Word, work in team-based environment, additional hours during summer season. Min. of 2 yrs exp. in similar position. F/T M-F 8-5 and 1 or 2 Sat. per mo, 9-2. $10.50/hr. Raises and benefits avail. in 3 mo. Submit cover letter with resume to: HR Dept., PO Box 822, Anacortes, WA 98221


Bilingual Apartment Maintenance Worker needed for affordable farm worker apartments. Must have two years experience, be personable and professional, and have valid WA State drivers license, insurance and reliable vehicle. Send resume to Almap@ccsww.org or call 360-424-3883


Cook for fast paced kitchen, must work clean, 1-3 shifts/week. Apply in person Thur. or Fri. 7-11am, Edison Cafe, 5797 Main St.


OTR, 11 Western States Canada Eligible a Plus Clean MVR & Background APPLY ONLINE www.knighttrans.com 206-767-1041 Class A CDL-Min 6 mos.


Mechanic's Helper, food equipment & refrigeration. Background and drug screen. $10-$15 DOE. 360-202-9460


Project Manager Assistant/ Grants Coordinator The Public Works Department of the Swinomish Tribal Community has an opening for a Project Manager Assistant/Grants Coordinator. The position will oversee assigned aspects of Tribal development projects and programs relating to their development, design, construction, inspection, and administration. 5 years of administrative experience, with at least two years work experience in an area related to work responsibilities. A high school diploma or equivalent is a must. Bachelor's Degree desired. Salary is up to $21.00 an hour with full benefits. Request a Swinomish Tribal Community application by calling (360) 466-1216 or e-mail to wbill@ swinomish.nsn.us Mail cover letter and resume along with the application to: Swinomish Tribal Community, Human Resource Office, 11404 Moorage Way, LaConner, WA. 98257