Recall effort is not justified in S-W dispute
Discuss (3 comments) | Email | Print Editorial Board | Skagit Valley Herald
August 29, 2008 - 03:58 PM

Citizen-initiated recalls of elected public officials are extreme — and occasionally necessary — reactions to conduct that is so contrary or damaging to the public interest that it must be immediately remedied by throwing someone out of office.

We don’t think that the actions of Sedro-Woolley Mayor Mike Anderson, as related to the Deluxe Recycling and Disposal dispute, rise to anything like the kind of malfeasance or corruption of public duty that would warrant the recall petition recently launched against him.

A recall is an instant and visceral plebiscite that inevitably will leave scars — and may not even achieve the desired result. The mayor is but one public official and doesn’t unilaterally control anything.

We understand the frustration of many Sedro-Woolley residents over the way the city has handled an application by Deluxe to build a garbage processing and recycling center near the high school. The level of resentment has boiled over to outrage for many people who believe that their elected and appointed public officials have ignored their concerns and protests in favor of a cushy business deal.

While city officials have sometimes characterized the controversy as a building permit discussion, it is of course more than that — and has mutated into something whose significance is well beyond the siting of a recycling center.

Our observations about the Deluxe proposal have focused on two issues: The perception by some residents that process has been skirted or subverted to the detriment of citizen participation, and that however laudable the Deluxe proposal might be, it must fit logically with an overall waste management plan for the county.

A recycling center might benefit Sedro-Woolley but make an efficient countywide system more difficult to achieve. The process question is something for the courts to work out now. The countywide waste management planning issue has yet to be satisfactorily addressed by Sedro-Woolley.

All that said, the movement to recall Anderson seems more personal than political. The mayor has been a lightning rod, as mayors often are, for the most vigorous objections to the proposal.

Disagreeing with public officials’ actions is one thing, and can ultimately be remedied at the polls. But even intense dissatisfaction with public policy must be accompanied by evidence of egregious misbehavior by the targeted official. However one feels about Mayor Anderson’s decisions, a recall has the appearance of over-reaching.

Editorials reflect the consensus opinion of the editorial board and are written by its members: Publisher L. Stedem Wood, Editor Don Nelson and City Editor Dick Clever. Signed columns reflect the authors’ viewpoints.

This article has been viewed 231 times


Discuss This Story (3 comments)



Previous Story

McCain taps Alaska governor for VP
 

Next Story

No more wifi at highway rest stops

More Local News


Top Jobs

Housekeeper 49 bed nursing home in Burlington. Exp. preferred but will train. Call Carol Smith for details,…


CASE AIDE P/T postion in Mt. Vernon area, evening, weekend, afternoon hours avail. Responsibilties: safe…


P/T Full Charge Bookkeeper for drywall and painting company. A/P, A/R, and payroll. Pay DOE. Must have…


Taxdel Heating is looking for an HVAC Installer. Experience req'd. Salary DOE. Call Tony @ 360-708-4675…


Busy chiropractic clinic looking for staff with good people and computer skills. Send resume with handwritten…


Curt Maberry Farm, grower & processor of berries in the Lynden area, is seeking applicants for a F/T…


Volume custom home builder looking for self-motivated energetic hourly & commission salesperson to work…


Automotive Technician New car dealership needing an experienced technician. This person would need to…


Sedro-Woolley ATTENTION: Skagit Valley Herald newspaper carriers wanted: SEDRO-WOOLLEY The Skagit Valley…


OPTICIAN for busy ophthalmology practice. Excellent opportunity for motivated person with great customer…


T BAILEY INC. is looking for Qualified Welders. 2 yrs exp. pref. on either Dual Shield or SubArc. MUST…


Transmission Outlet is looking for an experienced R&R Technician. Must have own tools. Top pay & benefits.…


Transportation Supervisor Mount Vernon School District No. 320 Supervisor responsible for safe/efficient…