By Dr. Tracy C. Miller
Special to The Argus
An Indian government official recently criticized the Bush administration for blaming the growing middle classes of developing countries, such as India and China, for rising food prices.
Although he may have misinterpreted the president’s remarks, his and other Indian critics’ responses are worth thinking about. They argue that the United States is the real culprit behind high food prices.
Has the United States played an important role in contributing to rising food prices and, if so, what should be done to correct the problem?
Growing world demand for food is part of the explanation for recent food price increases. Higher incomes of people in developing countries have enabled them to consume more calories and more meat, which has had an impact on food prices.
The fact that many people in the world can afford better diets is something we should be thankful for, even if it results in higher food prices for us. What should concern us, however, is how the U.S. government has contributed to the recent run-up in world food prices by subsidizing the production of bio-fuels.
While a variety of factors have contributed to food price increases, the actions of the U.S. government to promote the production of corn for ethanol cannot be ignored.
Joseph Glauber, the chief economist of the U.S. Department of Agriculture, predicts that 31 percent of the entire U.S. corn crop in 2008 and 2009 will be devoted to ethanol production. This growth in ethanol production is the result of the combination of a government mandate, a 51 cents per gallon tax credit for ethanol production, various other subsidies, and a 54 cents per gallon tariff on ethanol imports.
U.S. government mandates for increased ethanol production ignore economic reality, diverting a growing portion of U.S. cropland from food production without taking account of the cost of doing so.
As more land is used to produce corn, production of other crops has declined to the point where the United States has actually had to import wheat. Because the United States is a major producer and exporter of food and feed grains, reductions in U.S. output have a major impact on world food and feed prices. As more corn is diverted to ethanol production from feeding livestock, meat prices have risen as well.
Corn is a very expensive source of fuel, not just because of its value in feeding livestock, but because of the resources involved in converting it to fuel.
The amount of energy required to produce a gallon of ethanol is almost as much as the energy that results from burning the ethanol. When factoring in the other costs of using corn to produce ethanol, it should be evident why it is a waste of resources.
There is nothing inherently wrong with growing crops to produce fuel, even if doing so causes food prices to rise. Rather, the extent to which corn and other crops are used for fuel should be determined by the choices of consumers and producers in response to market prices that are unhampered by government intervention like those mentioned above — this is also known as free market prices. Because free market prices reflect people’s voluntary preferences, market prices serve as indicators of relative scarcity, reflecting the priorities of all who could potentially benefit from what could be produced from the land. Competition for resources in the market will result in those resources being used for purposes that consumers value the most.
Without market prices, government officials lack the ability to accurately estimate the net benefits of additional ethanol production for society. Unlike consumers, who bear the costs of their decisions through the prices they pay in the market, government officials do not bear the full costs associated with their decision to subsidize ethanol.
Ethanol subsidies and mandates also contribute to environmental degradation as more land is plowed and more pesticides are used to increase yields. They contribute to rising government deficits as well.
The only reason for politicians to continue these policies is that farmers and residents of rural communities, whose incomes increase as a result, will reward them with more votes.
If more Americans can become informed about how much this is costing the rest of us, perhaps our elected representatives will see that they might actually lose votes by continuing to support this waste of taxpayers’ money.
n Dr. Tracy C. Miller is an associate professor of economics at Grove City College and contributing scholar with the Center for Vision and Values. He holds a Ph.D. from University of Chicago.
Rising food prices: Who is to blame?
This article has been viewed 137 times
Previous Story• Accident leads to fatality at Janicki site |
Next Story• County recreation program comes to Sedro-Woolley |
More Local News
Top Jobs
Administrative Assistant Meridian Center Electric is currently taking applications for our full time…
Currently seeking SECURITY OFFICERS in the Anacortes area. Starting wage at $13.00. Applicants must be…
LPN NOC shift, wanted for MV dementia care residence. Very competitive wages. Benefits & a pleasant work…
Admin. Asst. 20 - 30 hrs/wk. Experience preferred but will train. Tammie @ Washington Iron Works, Inc.,…
Draft Pic's Sports Bar& Grill now hiring experienced Line Cook Top pay. Apply in person. 516 S. First…
Cheesemaking Opportunity in Bow. Will train, P/T or F/T option. PO Box 202, Bow, 98232 or cheese@ rootabaga.com…
Foundations Formsetters wanted. Exp. or will train. Wage DOE + benefits. 293-8387; Fax 293-8352
Assistant Bookkeeper Owner of a fast paced retail store seeking P/T assistant to help w/bookkeeping &…
Receptionist Looking for a receptionist to join our cosmetic skin care center. Must be enthusiastic,…
FRONT DESK HELP Good PR skills a must. Apply in person. Islands Inn, Anacortes
Dominos Pizza Drivers Wanted. Get cash every shift. 18 or older. Apply in person 1600 E. College Way.…
WE ARE HIRING!!! MARINE MECHANICS Preferred candidates will be MerCruiser or Volvo certified & have 3+…
Line Cook & Host/Counter Person Apply in person at Seed's Bistro or Calico Cupboard
#2008-603 2 Bus Drivers for the Anacortes School District. These positions are open until filled. Screening…
PERSONAL LINES CUSTOMER SERVICE AGENT: Wycoff Insurance is looking for a full time Personal Lines Customer…
HOUSECLEANERS wanted Mon.-Fri. for established Anacortes business. Must have vehicle & WDL. (360) 293-2349,…
Mount Vernon ATTENTION: Skagit Valley Herald newspaper carriers wanted: MOUNT VERNON The Skagit Valley…
AUTO MECHANIC wanted with experience. Must have own tools. Contact Steve at 360-856-2866
CNAs $1,000 sign on bonus Exciting new nursing mgmt ready for you to bring your skills to a beautiful…
Meat Cutter Trainee Up to $795 a week! Work 50-60 hrs a week, year round, for lots of overtime pay! English…
FARM TRUCK & TRACTOR OPERATOR. Valid drivers lic. req'd. 360-724-3375
GRAPHIC DESIGN POSITION The Skagit Valley Herald has an immediate opening in our graphic design department…
Specialty medical office seeks Clerical/ Receptionist F/T, Mon-Fri. Position req's organization, professional…
Licensed Vet Technician position available in busy small animal practice. Must be self-motivated and…
WA State Dept. of Agriculture is seeking a P/T POTATO INSPECTOR for the Mt. Vernon area. Applications…
ASSEMBLY $10-$10.50 hr Mon-Thurs, Friday off! Small electronic parts, clean, casual friendly environment.…
Database / Marketing Specialist We are seeking your excellent people skills to assist in our Marketing…
FOSTER CARE RESOURCES P/T Case Manager. Seeking professional person with good interpersonal skills, sound…
MEDICAL RECEPTIONIST 36+ hrs/week, M-F, 8-5 to work in the surgery scheduling dept. Looking for an individual…
MEDICAL ASSISTANT 32+ hrs/wk. Qualifications: Certification from an approved Medical Assistant program.…
YMCA Early Learning and After School centers in Mount Vernon & Anacortes now hiring for the following…
Here we Grow Again! We are expanding our sales team. Must have excellent communication and customer service…
La Conner Channel Lodge now accepting applications for Housekeeping Staff Flexible work days and a great…
Courier/Drivers F/T positions avail. Union pay & benefits. Call 360-707-5391
CNC MACHINIST Fast Paced Shop Wage DOE $22.00-$30.00 @ Hr, Benefits and Profit Sharing. Must Know MasterCam,…
Love iPods, GPS and Cell phones? Join our team! Full or Part time at Anacortes dealer store. Apply at…
Marine manufacturing and repair. Hiring laminator's, patch & detail. Min. 2 yrs exp. Call (360)398-1328…
911 Dispatchers We train. Start $17.62. Apps @ www.skagit911.com Return Mon-Thur 7am-4pm to 2911 E.College…
JOB SHOP MACHINIST Fast paced Shop Wage DOE $22.00-$30.00 @Hr, Benefits and Profit Sharing. Manual Machines…
REFINERY MAINTENANCE Tesoro is currently seeking to fill the following positions at its Anacortes refinery:…
#2008-707 AVID College Role Model TUTOR at the Anacortes School District. This position is open until…
Immediate openings for Washboard Laundry. Apply in person: 1806 Riverside Dr, MV
The Skagit Valley Herald is now hiring for: OUTSIDE ADVERTISING SALES Join our dynamic Outside Sales…
Due to growth and promotions, Josephine is hiring. • RN's LPN's - $2500 Sign on Bonus Afternoons 2pm-10:30pm…
Per Dona Salon and Spa is under new ownership and looking for a P/T or F/T Spa Coordinator/ Receptionist…
TABLE GAMES DEALERS Base Pay & Tips 1 skilled $7.00/hr. 2 skilled $7.75/hr 3 skilled $8.50/hr 4 skilled…
Mount Vernon ATTENTION: Skagit Valley Herald newspaper carriers wanted: MOUNT VERNON The Skagit Valley…
CAREGIVERS NEEDED! PT NAC/NAR with current CPR and First Aid. Mental health and dementia training a plus.…
OPHTHALMIC ASSISTANT Looking for an organized person w/ the ability to multi-task, must have customer…
Marketing Assistant Full-Time Do you enjoy working with elderly people? We are seeking a gracious individual,…
Director of Nursing Skilled Nursing Facility with Nursing staff of 60 in a beautiful Cascade setting.…
RNs $2,000 sign-on bonus! LPNs $1,500 sign-on bonus! Bring your skills to a beautiful Cascade setting.…
2 DISTRICT ASSISTANTS 20+ hours a week. Job duties include but are not limited to: • 4AM - 8AM • $8.50/hour…
Training & Development Manager Whidbey Island Bank is seeking applicants for a Training & Development…
JEWELRY SALES AND JEWELRY MANAGERS, F/T, self motivated, custom design and more! 360-707-5444
Currently seeking SECURITY OFFICERS in the Anacortes area. Starting wage at $13.00. Applicants must be…
LPN NOC shift, wanted for MV dementia care residence. Very competitive wages. Benefits & a pleasant work…
Admin. Asst. 20 - 30 hrs/wk. Experience preferred but will train. Tammie @ Washington Iron Works, Inc.,…
Draft Pic's Sports Bar& Grill now hiring experienced Line Cook Top pay. Apply in person. 516 S. First…
Cheesemaking Opportunity in Bow. Will train, P/T or F/T option. PO Box 202, Bow, 98232 or cheese@ rootabaga.com…
Foundations Formsetters wanted. Exp. or will train. Wage DOE + benefits. 293-8387; Fax 293-8352
Assistant Bookkeeper Owner of a fast paced retail store seeking P/T assistant to help w/bookkeeping &…
Receptionist Looking for a receptionist to join our cosmetic skin care center. Must be enthusiastic,…
FRONT DESK HELP Good PR skills a must. Apply in person. Islands Inn, Anacortes
Dominos Pizza Drivers Wanted. Get cash every shift. 18 or older. Apply in person 1600 E. College Way.…
WE ARE HIRING!!! MARINE MECHANICS Preferred candidates will be MerCruiser or Volvo certified & have 3+…
Line Cook & Host/Counter Person Apply in person at Seed's Bistro or Calico Cupboard
#2008-603 2 Bus Drivers for the Anacortes School District. These positions are open until filled. Screening…
PERSONAL LINES CUSTOMER SERVICE AGENT: Wycoff Insurance is looking for a full time Personal Lines Customer…
HOUSECLEANERS wanted Mon.-Fri. for established Anacortes business. Must have vehicle & WDL. (360) 293-2349,…
Mount Vernon ATTENTION: Skagit Valley Herald newspaper carriers wanted: MOUNT VERNON The Skagit Valley…
AUTO MECHANIC wanted with experience. Must have own tools. Contact Steve at 360-856-2866
CNAs $1,000 sign on bonus Exciting new nursing mgmt ready for you to bring your skills to a beautiful…
Meat Cutter Trainee Up to $795 a week! Work 50-60 hrs a week, year round, for lots of overtime pay! English…
FARM TRUCK & TRACTOR OPERATOR. Valid drivers lic. req'd. 360-724-3375
GRAPHIC DESIGN POSITION The Skagit Valley Herald has an immediate opening in our graphic design department…
Specialty medical office seeks Clerical/ Receptionist F/T, Mon-Fri. Position req's organization, professional…
Licensed Vet Technician position available in busy small animal practice. Must be self-motivated and…
WA State Dept. of Agriculture is seeking a P/T POTATO INSPECTOR for the Mt. Vernon area. Applications…
ASSEMBLY $10-$10.50 hr Mon-Thurs, Friday off! Small electronic parts, clean, casual friendly environment.…
Database / Marketing Specialist We are seeking your excellent people skills to assist in our Marketing…
FOSTER CARE RESOURCES P/T Case Manager. Seeking professional person with good interpersonal skills, sound…
MEDICAL RECEPTIONIST 36+ hrs/week, M-F, 8-5 to work in the surgery scheduling dept. Looking for an individual…
MEDICAL ASSISTANT 32+ hrs/wk. Qualifications: Certification from an approved Medical Assistant program.…
YMCA Early Learning and After School centers in Mount Vernon & Anacortes now hiring for the following…
Here we Grow Again! We are expanding our sales team. Must have excellent communication and customer service…
La Conner Channel Lodge now accepting applications for Housekeeping Staff Flexible work days and a great…
Courier/Drivers F/T positions avail. Union pay & benefits. Call 360-707-5391
CNC MACHINIST Fast Paced Shop Wage DOE $22.00-$30.00 @ Hr, Benefits and Profit Sharing. Must Know MasterCam,…
Love iPods, GPS and Cell phones? Join our team! Full or Part time at Anacortes dealer store. Apply at…
Marine manufacturing and repair. Hiring laminator's, patch & detail. Min. 2 yrs exp. Call (360)398-1328…
911 Dispatchers We train. Start $17.62. Apps @ www.skagit911.com Return Mon-Thur 7am-4pm to 2911 E.College…
JOB SHOP MACHINIST Fast paced Shop Wage DOE $22.00-$30.00 @Hr, Benefits and Profit Sharing. Manual Machines…
REFINERY MAINTENANCE Tesoro is currently seeking to fill the following positions at its Anacortes refinery:…
#2008-707 AVID College Role Model TUTOR at the Anacortes School District. This position is open until…
Immediate openings for Washboard Laundry. Apply in person: 1806 Riverside Dr, MV
The Skagit Valley Herald is now hiring for: OUTSIDE ADVERTISING SALES Join our dynamic Outside Sales…
Due to growth and promotions, Josephine is hiring. • RN's LPN's - $2500 Sign on Bonus Afternoons 2pm-10:30pm…
Per Dona Salon and Spa is under new ownership and looking for a P/T or F/T Spa Coordinator/ Receptionist…
TABLE GAMES DEALERS Base Pay & Tips 1 skilled $7.00/hr. 2 skilled $7.75/hr 3 skilled $8.50/hr 4 skilled…
Mount Vernon ATTENTION: Skagit Valley Herald newspaper carriers wanted: MOUNT VERNON The Skagit Valley…
CAREGIVERS NEEDED! PT NAC/NAR with current CPR and First Aid. Mental health and dementia training a plus.…
OPHTHALMIC ASSISTANT Looking for an organized person w/ the ability to multi-task, must have customer…
Marketing Assistant Full-Time Do you enjoy working with elderly people? We are seeking a gracious individual,…
Director of Nursing Skilled Nursing Facility with Nursing staff of 60 in a beautiful Cascade setting.…
RNs $2,000 sign-on bonus! LPNs $1,500 sign-on bonus! Bring your skills to a beautiful Cascade setting.…
2 DISTRICT ASSISTANTS 20+ hours a week. Job duties include but are not limited to: • 4AM - 8AM • $8.50/hour…
Training & Development Manager Whidbey Island Bank is seeking applicants for a Training & Development…
JEWELRY SALES AND JEWELRY MANAGERS, F/T, self motivated, custom design and more! 360-707-5444
