The rising price of justice
13 Comments | Email | Print | 1318 views Ralph Schwartz | Skagit Valley Herald
June 22, 2009 - 08:02 AM
Last Updated: June 22, 2009 - 08:05 AM

The first cost estimate in four years for a new Skagit County jail has created some sticker shock.

The new number is so high — almost $150 million to construct a facility that would house 708 inmates — that the small number of county officials who have seen the report won’t brief the county commissioners on it anytime soon.

The first phase of the project includes only 428 beds and was expected to cost $49 million in 2005. Now the cost per square foot has doubled, and with demolition and other site costs not considered in 2005, the new price tag is $115 million just for the first phase.

“That’s high,” said Charlie Wend, a state community corrections supervisor who has been on the county Law and Justice Council since its inception in 1994. Although Wend is one of the project leads for the new jail, he hadn’t seen the cost report, made available to the county in the first week of June, until a reporter showed it to him Tuesday.

Still, the cost wasn’t a complete surprise to Wend.

“I knew all along this thing was going to be costly,” he said.

Under the current plan, the new jail would have more than just cells. It would include courtrooms, county attorneys’ offices, and mental health and chemical dependency treatment centers.

‘The full-meal deal’

One of the biggest reasons for the increased expense is the architect’s proposal to elevate the jail 12 feet above ground to provide parking underneath the building and keep the first floor well above flood level.

At that height, the foundation alone would cost $17 million for the full, 708-bed facility, which could be needed as early as 2025, according to the 2005 report.

The county commissioners selected the Alf Christianson Seed facility south of Kincaid Street in downtown Mount Vernon as the site of the proposed jail. The soil in the area is so unstable that the jail would need to be built on pilings set 90 feet into the ground, according to the architect’s report.

“You’re building on quicksand, basically,” county Capital Facilities Manager Al Jongsma said.

Jongsma, one of a small number of county officials who have studied the report since it arrived earlier this month, believes he can find ways to cut costs significantly.

“I’m not comfortable at this point saying this is the best we can do with our cost figures,” he said. “I’m all about trying to reduce this cost.”

That’s why the commissioners won’t be fully briefed on the report for about 60 days, Jongsma said. He wants to use that time to bring the bottom line down to a more realistic level.

County Administrator Tim Holloran, who also has seen the report, said that scaling back the jail plan is not only possible, but it may be necessary in the current economic climate.

“It’s the full-meal deal, and our economy is the brown-bag lunch,” Holloran said. “It may not be the best design.”

Jongsma, who has a background in construction, said there are two ways to save money on the foundation. Either eliminate the ground-level parking and buy more land for a parking lot, or make the building that sits on the pilings lighter, using less expensive materials.

Jongsma would recommend eliminating the parking under the building, but the decision will first be addressed by the Law and Justice Council and ultimately by the commissioners, he said.

To meet current flood-protection requirements, any building constructed on the Christianson Seed property must be at least 2 feet above ground level in any case.

The voters decide

Building and then running a new jail will involve other costs that aren’t yet known. Jongsma is waiting for an appraisal of the 10-acre Christianson Seed property, which he said was two weeks overdue on Wednesday.

The property would certainly cost the county several million dollars. The land alone on the two largest parcels on the property, about 6 acres, was valued at $2.3 million in 2008 by the County Assessor’s Office.

As county officials try to figure out how to pay for the new jail, they also must factor in the cost of day-to-day operations — mainly the salaries paid to jail staff. County Budget and Finance Director Trisha Logue said she doesn’t have an estimate for operating costs yet. The 2005 estimate for operating costs, based on a slightly smaller jail and the lower wages of that time, was $4.3 million a year.

County officials are planning for a ballot measure that would ask voters for a tax increase to pay for the jail.

The commissioners have said they are more likely to ask voters for a sales tax increase to finance the jail, rather than the potentially more unpopular property tax hike.

State law allows a maximum sales tax increase of 0.3 percent for law and justice programs.

Logue said a consultant is still working out how much the 0.3 percent increase would raise for a new jail.

There may be grant money available for energy-efficient construction or drug treatment, but the county has found nothing definite, Logue said.

Forty percent of any additional sales-tax revenue approved by voters would go directly to the cities. County officials said the cities need to agree to funnel that money to the county so it can pay off the bond, or else bear higher daily rates for putting people in the jail.

“It needs to be a partnership both of will and of money,” Commissioner Sharon Dillon said. “They (the cities) need to believe in this, too.”

The measure won’t be on the ballot until next spring at the earliest, county officials have said.


‘We can’t wait’

The jail’s Web site, http://www.skagitcounty.net/jail, includes a weekly statistics page that reports how many people were arrested but not jailed due to overcrowding, and how many inmates were released early because jail staff needed the bed for someone else.

The current jail, completed in 1984 and designed to house 83 inmates, was later remodeled to hold 180 beds. For the week ending June 13, the jail averaged 214 inmates.

In that same week, seven inmates were released early to relieve overcrowding, and 20 people who were arrested never made it to jail because there was no room.

On Tuesday, Chief Corrections Officer Gary Shand hadn’t seen the architect’s cost estimate, so he could not comment on it.

“I will tell you one thing: We can’t wait. There’s just no way we can wait,” Shand said.

Another reason the jail is relatively expensive is that the plans include functions not found in the current jail: more courtrooms, and programs to help people manage mental illness or overcome alcoholism and drug addiction.

Wend, the government official who has worked on the jail proposal the longest, didn’t want to see the new facility reduced to what he called a warehouse for offenders. “Reducing recidivism” is the mantra that law and justice officials won’t easily give up.

“The sense I’ve had from a lot of the public is they want that treatment component included,” Wend said. “In the long run, you save lots of dollars that way, and you prevent crime.”

Commissioner Dillon, who is still months away from any major decisions on the jail, has spoken in favor of bringing treatment services inside the new jail. Last week, however, she was reluctantly willing to leave those services out, at least in the first phase, if the result is a jail the community can afford.

“It may not be something we can ask the voters to do,” Dillon said of the more expensive option.

Ralph Schwartz can be reached at 360-416-2138 or .





Read all 13 comments / share your thoughts
Latest comments

Well WalMart is moving to a new and better location.  The parking lot is a pretty good size and the building is big. Its a good place to start. …

Posted July 01, 2009 - 06:59 PM by jude

There are often 300 in jail now, but they are only the worst of the worst, dangerous ones needing to be confined until sentencing or serving their time. …

Posted June 27, 2009 - 07:12 PM by noodles

mykodragon, I completly agree with everything you said.  It’s stupid to think of jail as a business but that’s exactly what they are…

Posted June 26, 2009 - 04:30 AM by ProudVet


Read all 13 comments / share your thoughts


More Local News

Top Jobs

REFINERY OPERATOR Tesoro is currently seeking to fill the position of Refinery Operator at its Anacortes facility. An Operator monitors and controls refinery process equipment while working a rotating 12-hour shift, often outdoors in a variety of weather conditions. This can be a physically/mentally challenging job requiring mechanical ability and a basic understanding of physical sciences and chemistry. In addition, candidates must possess a positive work ethic, good communications and teamworking skills and have the willingness to take personal responsibility for the safety of themselves and others. Along with a dynamic work environment, Tesoro offers an excellent compensation and benefits package. Starting wage will be $21.38 per hour that will initially increase to $25.59 after successful completion of training. Employment applications (one application per person) can be obtained at the Work Source Skagit, 2005 E. College Way, in Mount Vernon during the hours 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., on November 24, 25, and 30, 2009, or until a maximum of 300 applications has been distributed. No applications will be faxed or mailed. You must apply in person. All applicants will be tested on Saturday, December 5, 2009, for basic skills and aptitude. Additional information will be provided with the application. Telephone inquiries and mail-in applications will not be accepted. Successful candidates for employment will be required to pass a substance abuse screening (drug and alcohol), physical agility tests, and complete a physical exam. Tesoro Refining and Marketing Company 10200 W. March Point Rd. Anacortes, WA 98221 Equal Opportunity Employer M/F/D/V


FARMERS INSURANCE AGENT We are looking for career motivated people to join our team. Join our team full time or train while you keep your current job to ensure a comfortable transition into the industry. Take advantage of top notch training, unlimited income potential, and the flexibility our company offers. Call Michael Dame at (360) 714 8117 x204 or email resume to mdame@farmersagent.com


PROGRAM MANAGER developmentally disabled adults. Responsible for the overall day-to-day functioning of this supported living program. The Manager participates in hiring staff, training staff, scheduling of staff. BA or equiv plus 2 yrs working with the people we serve in a residential setting. At least 2-3 yrs. experience as a supervisor + direct service. Volunteers of America Western Washington is a private non-profit human service agency serving the disabled in Skagit County. Come be a part of what we do and make a difference every day. EEO/AA If you wish to apply for this position, send a resume to bdavis@voaww.org or come to 1934 E. College Way, Mount Vernon, WA 98273.


Youth Center Staff Supervisor The Swinomish Tribal Community Recreation/ Prevention Department is looking for a dynamic and competent individual who is experienced as a Youth Center Staff Supervisor. The Youth Center Supervisor plans, and does the total duties of a Prevention/Recreation Assistant. This position provides leadership to the other assistants when the Coordinator is out of the office. The Swinomish Tribal Community is a positive and friendly work environment. This is a full-time position with full health insurance benefits. Salary is DOQ. Request a Swinomish Tribal Community application and Job Description by calling 360-466-1216 or e-mail wbill@swinomish.nsn.us. Return cover letter, resume, and application to Wayne Bill, Human Resource Director as soon as possible. Send application packet to; Swinomish Tribal Community, Human Resource Office, 11404 Moorage Way, LaConner, WA. 98257


LIVE-IN CAREGIVER. Room and board furnished. Clean, cook, secretarial, farm management. Integrity required. 360-873-9600


STYLIST for AVEDA SALON AND SPA. Commission. 1019 Cleveland St., MV 336-2985


Established medical office seeks Medical Records Clerk/Receptionist. Must be flex. Position also covers sick & vacation days. You must have computer, customer service and professional telephone skills. Applicant must be neat in appearance, pleasant, reliable, organized, energetic and able to multi-task. Previous medical exp. is helpful but not nec. Send resume to: bonniec-mvwc @verizon.net or File #676 c/o Skagit Valley Herald, PO Box 578, Mount Vernon, WA 98273.


Housekeeping/Laundry Experience preferred but will also train. Must be available days, weekends and holidays. $10.50 - $12.50 DOQ Join our team and enjoy a full complement of benefits including medical and life insurance at no charge to the employee, dental, paid sick leave, paid vacation, paid holidays, and a 401K plan. Must be able to pass a background check and a 90 day drug screen. For more info., please contact Human Resources at 360-724-0265 or visit our website: www.theskagit.com Human Resources Hours: M-F, 8am to 5pm Directions: North or southbound - Take I-5 to Exit 236